Optimizing GitHub Sync in User Authentication

Introduction

In our ongoing efforts to improve application performance and user experience, we identified an issue with the GitHub synchronization process during user logins. Initially, the sync process was triggered during every login, leading to unnecessary load and performance degradation for returning users. Through diligent code review and collaborative efforts, we have now refactored the synchronization strategy to optimize performance significantly.

The Challenge

The original implementation of GitHub sync included a line of code that executed the dispatchGitHubSync method every time a user logged in, regardless of whether they were a new or returning user. This redundancy created several challenges:

• Increased load on the system due to unnecessary sync actions returning users.
• Slower response times for authenticated sessions, affecting the overall user experience.

To alleviate these issues, it was crucial to limit the synchronization process to essential scenarios only—specifically, during user registration and when explicitly requested by the user through a scheduled sync.

The Solution

We addressed the challenge by modifying the logic in the callback method of the SocialiteController. Now, synchronization is only triggered under the following conditions:

1. When a new user registers for the first time.
2. When a scheduled auto-sync is enabled by the user.

Here is the key part of the refactored code:

public function callback(Request $request): RedirectResponse
{
    // ... other logic

    // Sync with GitHub only if the user is a new registrant
    if ($this->isNewUser($user)) {
        $this->dispatchGitHubSync($user);
    }

    return redirect()->away(tenantUrl($request, $user->username, 'admin'));
}

This change ensures that the dispatchGitHubSync method is no longer called for returning users, reducing the unnecessary processing overhead.

Test Adjustments

In parallel with these changes, we updated our test suite to validate the new behavior. The following snippet reflects the adjustments in our test case:

public function test_github_login_does_not_dispatch_sync_job_for_existing_user(): void
{
    Queue::fake();

    // Simulate a returning user login
    $this->get(route('socialite.callback'));

    // Assert sync job is not pushed for returning user
    Queue::assertNotPushed(SyncGitHubActivityJob::class);
}

This test ensures that our sync functionality operates correctly, providing increased confidence in the refactoring.

Results

The impact of these changes has been notable:

• Performance Improvements: Reduced server load on user logins and improved response times for returning users.
• Enhanced User Experience: Users experience faster logins without unnecessary delays caused by background processes.
• Cleaner Codebase: This refactoring promotes better maintainability with a clear separation of concerns.

Lessons Learned

Through this optimization process, we learned the importance of evaluating existing workflows critically, especially regarding system performance. By refocusing our sync logic and ensuring it aligns with user scenarios, we create a more efficient and user-friendly system.

Conclusion

In summary, the refinement of our GitHub sync strategy represents a key step in enhancing our application's performance. This journey has underscored the necessity for ongoing evaluation and adaptation of code to meet evolving user needs. We encourage developers to continuously assess their authentication workflows and adopt similar optimizations for improved performance and user satisfaction.

Generated with Devlog.ist